Football May 31, 2026

Q&A: Was VAR call for Celtic penalty at Motherwell ‘clear cut’ or ‘worst decision in history’?

👤
By Admin
Sports Journalist
Q&A: Was VAR call for Celtic penalty at Motherwell ‘clear cut’ or ‘worst decision in history’?

It is the decision that has got the footballing world talking. Celtic’s match-winning penalty at Fir Park.

Was it a handball? Was it a header? What does it mean for the Scottish Premiership title race?

Here are the key questions answered following another dramatic twist in the most unforgettable season...

The final whistle had gone at Tynecastle to seal a win for Hearts. Celtic were seconds away from drawing at Motherwell, which would have seen Hearts go to Celtic on the final day with a three-point lead.

Then, Motherwell's Sam Nicholson jumped up with Celtic's Auston Trusty to try to head the ball from a long throw-in. Nicholson's elbow was raised and was perhaps pushed further up by Trusty's shoulder.

The game stopped for a VAR check. Was that for an elbow? No. The stadium PA announced it was in fact for handball.

Many have noted that the Celtic appeals for a penalty were limited. Trusty lay on the pitch following the collision with Nicholson and held his head. He went on to complain to referee John Beaton about being elbowed by the Motherwell player. However, there were no real claims for a handball at the time.

The three words that have been associated with VAR.

Debate has raged about whether the ball came off Nicholson's hand or if it only hit his head.

The way the ball flew back out of play for a throw-in suggests it came off his head, so VAR must believe it came off his hand at the same time.

If there is doubt, can it be deemed as a clear and obvious error for the VAR to intervene?

After VAR Andrew Dallas advised referee John Beaton to carry out an on-field review, he was at the VAR screen for around 22 seconds as officials used the one angle that best showed the incident. From that, it was decided Nicholson's hand was in an unnatural position, resulting in a penalty for handball.

Yes, Kelechi Iheanacho's penalty hit the net with the clock at 98:27. Yes, there were only five minutes of added time. However, the handball offence itself took place at 94:52 - that's eight seconds within the added time initially indicated by the officials.

Well, some eagle-eyed Motherwell supporters believe the throw-in that resulted in the penalty was in-fact a foul-throw. The image below could prove their point. However, it is important to know VAR can't intervene in that.

It's a bold claim, but Motherwell's Elliot Watt believes so as he tweeted "the worst VAR decision in history". His manager Jens Berthel Askou wasn't impressed either and said: "I thought I'd seen it all this year, but apparently I haven't. It's shocking.

"Even if he touches with his fingernail, it's because there's contact when he goes up. His arm is here, then he gets pushed into it, so it would never be a penalty anyway."

It might be no surprise that the two bosses battling for the title had contrasting views. Celtic manager Martin O'Neill said the decision "looks as if it's a pretty clear cut" and added "he's given it for the handball, and also an elbow on top of that there as well".

Hearts head coach Derek McInnes disagreed. "It's disgusting," he said. "I don't think it's a penalty kick. We're up against it, we're up against everybody and we'll be ready for Saturday."

Referee Beaton and VAR Dallas were certainly busy at Fir Park. In the first half they checked and dismissed an appeal from Celtic for a penalty after Motherwell goalkeeper Calum Ward collided with Daizen Maeda in the box as he tried to clear the ball.

Kris Boyd felt there was a mistake here too. "This could be a penalty," he said. "The goalkeeper makes contact with Maeda before anything else."

Later, they also rejected Motherwell spot-kick claims when Callum Slattery went down in the area. Despite claims for a foul by Callum McGregor on Slattery, Boyd backed the referee's decision and said: "I think he slips."

Boyd believes this VAR decision is the latest that has resulted in a boost for Celtic's title bid and said it was "another dubious call which has gone in Celtic's favour".

He's referring to Steven McLean's decision not to award a penalty to Hearts against Motherwell on Saturday, despite being sent to the monitor by VAR, plus Celtic's Alistair Johnston avoiding a red card in the Old Firm game last Sunday.

Yes. The club's largest shareholder - the Foundation of Hearts - issued a statement noting they are "extremely concerned by a number of refereeing and VAR decisions across the last two rounds of fixtures, which have had a significant impact on outcomes for Hearts and others". They added that "the club shares these concerns and has made representations to the football authorities seeking clarification on recent decisions".

Before that penalty was awarded, Hearts had already won against Falkirk and Celtic were set to drop two points. That would have seen leaders Hearts have a three-point advantage heading into the final day, plus a superior goal difference of six.

When the ball left the spot and hit the net, the gap was down to one point and the goal difference was down to five.

Quite simple. Ninety minutes. Two teams. One title.

Should Celtic win at home to Hearts, they are champions again. If Hearts win, or even draw, then it is them who will be champions.

The Scottish FA have appointed Don Robertson to take charge of the game at Parkhead, with Kevin Clancy on VAR.

Your Site Football. Live from 11.30am. Kick-off at 12.30pm. Don't miss it.

Tags:

football news

Share this article

Related Posts

West Ham vs Arsenal: PGMO to 'be vigilant' over grappling at set pieces after 'clear and obvious' foul on David Raya

West Ham vs Arsenal: PGMO to 'be vigilant' over grappling at set pieces after 'clear and obvious' foul on David Raya

Chief refereeing officer Howard Webb says the PGMO will continue to "be vigilant" over "impactful" grappling at set pieces following the "clear and ob...

Xabi Alonso: Former Real Madrid and Bayer Leverkusen coach has dilemma of moving to Chelsea or waiting for 'dream' Liverpool job

Xabi Alonso: Former Real Madrid and Bayer Leverkusen coach has dilemma of moving to Chelsea or waiting for 'dream' Liverpool job

Xabi Alonso has a big decision to make if he is offered the Chelsea job.Managing Chelsea is still an attractive option for leading managers, but they...

Ben White injury: Arsenal and England defender a major doubt for World Cup as knee issue ends season

Ben White injury: Arsenal and England defender a major doubt for World Cup as knee issue ends season

Arsenal defender Ben White will miss the rest of the season with a medial ligament injury, and it is understood he is unlikely to be fit for the World...

Real Madrid president Florentino Perez back in the spotlight after astonishing press conference

Real Madrid president Florentino Perez back in the spotlight after astonishing press conference

Florentino Perez left journalists and Spanish football stunned with his performance at a press conference on Tuesday after claiming he was the victim...

Benjamin Sesko: Howard Webb believes Man Utd forward handled ball vs Liverpool but VAR could not disallow due to lack of evidence

Benjamin Sesko: Howard Webb believes Man Utd forward handled ball vs Liverpool but VAR could not disallow due to lack of evidence

Howard Webb believes the ball hit Benjamin Sesko's hand as he scored for Manchester United against Liverpool - but also says VAR could not disallow th...

Motherwell 2-3 Celtic: Kelechi Iheanacho scores 100th-minute penalty to clinch comeback win and take Scottish Premiership title race to final day

Motherwell 2-3 Celtic: Kelechi Iheanacho scores 100th-minute penalty to clinch comeback win and take Scottish Premiership title race to final day

Kelechi Iheanacho's controversial 100th-minute penalty to grab Celtic a 3-2 win at Motherwell sent the Scottish Premiership title race to the final da...